AI in School: Is It Really the Villain?

170 Views

 

When calculators first entered classrooms, many parents worried. “Children will forget how to count!” they said. Similar concerns arose with the internet and, long before that, the printing press. Today, it is hard to imagine schools without these tools.

Now, AI faces similar criticism. Some believe it makes students lazy, distracted, and less capable of learning. But is the problem really the tool, or does it depend on how we use it?

It explains without making students feel embarrassed. Not every child understands a lesson the first time. AI allows students to ask questions, request simpler explanations, and try again without feeling uncomfortable.

It helps shy students find their voice. Some students have wonderful ideas but hesitate to share them in class. Talking through ideas with AI can help them practise expressing their opinions and gradually gain confidence in speaking up.

It teaches students to question answers. AI can make mistakes, and that gives students an opportunity to check facts, compare information, and think critically rather than believe everything they read.

Where AI Sparks Thinking, Not Replaces It. In my Grade 6 class, students held a live voice debate with an AI on “Should exams be banned?” The aim was to strengthen their listening, critical thinking, and ability to defend a position with reasoned arguments. Speaking aloud with no script to lean on, they listened closely, challenged the AI’s claims, and justified their own views in real time. What stood out most was their curiosity and openness: because the AI offered a low-pressure, emotionally safe space, students took intellectual risks they might hesitate to take in front of peers. The AI did not do their thinking for them; it gave them a reason to think more deeply, and that is exactly what made the experience so effective.

Of course, challenges remain. Despite guidance, some students may copy and paste AI-generated answers instead of making their own effort. This is why we must teach them to use AI responsibly while valuing independent thought.

So, is AI the villain, or can it become a useful learning tool? Perhaps the real question is not whether AI belongs in our classrooms, but how we prepare children to use it wisely.

What do you think?

Written By: Ms. Beeta Yakoob

English Language/Literature Teacher